PHOTO BY STEVE HINRICHS.
Residents of Springfield’s Hawthorne Place neighborhood joined with different activists in calling for adoption of a 2024 metropolis ordinance designed to weed out therapeutic massage parlors providing illicit companies and cut back human trafficking. Amongst those that labored on the problem and proceed to name for aggressive enforcement of the ordinance are (from left) Kaitlyn Eager, Jenna Duffy, Crystal Commean, Julia Rozier, Josh Turner, Stacey Hayes, Kathy Ward, David Baker and Vaida Eager.
We welcome letters. Please embrace your full identify, deal with and phone quantity. We edit all letters. Ship them to [email protected].
—
WORDS MATTER
As somebody who’s a part of the native Asian neighborhood who has heard from therapeutic massage remedy homeowners being negatively affected by this rhetoric, I’m speaking that this has brought on hurt (“Combating human trafficking,” Feb. 20). Please take into account referencing the companies as illicit therapeutic massage parlors – which you will have completed most instances – that might be concerned in human trafficking and victimizing Asian ladies. The truth that they’re being marketed as Asian therapeutic massage parlors in itself stereotypes Asian therapeutic massage institutions, staining the lengthy historical past of Chinese language medication and therapeutic strategies during which we take delight.
There’s additionally the truth that race is never highlighted when writing a few enterprise, particularly in relation to white-owned companies. How is it that some races turn out to be hyper-visible when information businesses routinely do not point out race for essentially the most half total? Any enterprise proprietor, no matter race, is free to make use of Chinese language characters of their branding. Whether or not or not it’s acceptable is one other dialog.
There’s additionally no proof that there aren’t any illicit therapeutic massage parlors that contain non-Asian employees, so you’re utilizing assumption and generalization right here, once more, inflicting hurt to the Asian neighborhood. I recognize the article utilizing the time period “illicit therapeutic massage parlors” more often than not, and I ask that you simply use “Asian” solely once you discuss concerning the ladies who could also be pressured to work there, not as a denominator for the companies themselves. This may spotlight their marginalized id as they’re victimized by and are survivors of horrendous human trafficking and intercourse trafficking crimes, calling consideration to the truth that we have to dedicate sources to assist them.
In characterizing all Asian-owned/concerned therapeutic massage parlors with criminality, it reinforces broader stereotypes that have an effect on different Asian-owned companies within the space. Comparable stereotyping harmed Asian-owned eating places and companies in the course of the pandemic, most not too long ago, although these patterns of thought have additionally been used throughout World Battle II to be able to disenfranchise Japanese People, and within the nineteenth century to devalue Chinese language American labor.
The phrases we use matter, and when discussing such an vital subject in a divided time, they have to be used responsibly. Please take into account referring to the now-closed companies with phrases like “illicit,” “unlawful” or “noncompliant” fairly than solely broad ones like “Asian parlors.” In any other case, it portrays an image of racism and casts the Asian race as the issue, when in actuality, those that needs to be held accountable are homeowners (once more, usually white) and patrons who trigger and have interaction within the struggling of survivors of human trafficking.
As journalists, you will have the nice job of informing the general public, and it additionally comes with the duty of not inflicting hurt to our neighborhood. At a time when the Asian neighborhood and different immigrant communities face elevated xenophobia and discrimination, I sincerely ask that our voices be heard and our opinions be valued. You’ve gotten the ability in making the mandatory corrections and to alleviate hurt.
Lingling Liu
Springfield
—
THE WOMEN MATTER
Shutting down these locations with out truly doing something to assist the ladies and women working there is not engaging in something. What did the town, regulation enforcement or anybody do to seek out these ladies (who apparently all disappeared when the locations have been closed, in keeping with the article), get them reputable shelter, counseling or authorized illustration? They’ll simply be moved someplace else, which solves nothing.
Zuzu Casey
By way of Facebook.com/illinoistimes
—
ZONING MATTERS
Who knew you must test zoning earlier than spending a measly couple of million on a property? It might seem the epic fail was on the behalf of the property purchaser (“Manufacturing operations shifting to Clinton,” Feb. 27).
It’s unhappy that the town of Springfield could not get this resolved in an amicable style for Kwik-Wall, however finally it’s the burden of the purchaser to verify the property is zoned for the meant use.
On this case, failure to plan led to a plan for failure.
Terry Younger
Springfield
