If Metropolis Council members approve an $830 million bond concern this week, Chicago taxpayers can anticipate to be on the hook long-term for the prices — which might be greater — due to a persistent lack of fiscal self-discipline and an administration detest to contemplate any trims to its price range.
Normal & Poor’s World grew to become the newest bond score company to decrease the town’s score to simply above junk standing, saying the administration seems unwilling to even take into account chopping spending.
The day after that downgrade, so as to add insult to damage, Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration supplied its plan to borrow $830 million extra.
In latest months I’ve warned that the credit standing businesses are watching and have voiced concern about this administration’s spending.
“The score motion additionally displays our view that following the 2025 price range negotiations, the town’s sensible choices for elevating new income seem much less sure, as does the willingness of metropolis management to chop spending, making a stage of uncertainty round its monetary trajectory that’s extra appropriately mirrored within the decrease score,” S&P Global mentioned in its report decreasing the town’s bond score from BBB+ to BBB, two ranges above junk bond standing.
Because the state’s chief fiscal and accountability officer, I’ve labored arduous over the previous eight years to convey the state’s credit standing again up from the place the earlier administrations sunk it. I saved state taxpayers $82 million in curiosity by repaying a $2 billion COVID-19 mortgage two years early. After 20 years of credit score downgrades, the state of Illinois has loved 9 straight credit score upgrades on my watch.
Finance Committee Vice-Chair Ald. Invoice Conway’s evaluation of the phrases of the compensation schedule made clear that this bond deal will get monumentally worse by the second.
As ill-advised and tone-deaf because it was for the Johnson administration to hunt a further $830 million in bonding lower than 24 hours after having its credit score downgraded, it could be completely reckless to construction it as an interest-only deal that defers principal for the primary 20 years, because the Johnson administration reportedly plans. Paying solely curiosity and no principal for the primary 20 years would take the price of the $830 million bond deal to upwards of $2 billion. This shortsighted money seize is a full rip-off on taxpayers and must be stopped. It could very seemingly invite one other credit score downgrade plunging the town into junk territory.
Spell out compensation plan
If that’s not the administration’s plan, they should spell out for Metropolis Council members and taxpayers what their compensation plan is.
As our earlier governor introduced on 9 consecutive downgrades, he mentioned, “Don’t hearken to Wall Road,” and his downgrades finally price Illinois taxpayers cash. The mayor of Chicago ought to hearken to Wall Road. He doesn’t have to love buyers. However he ought to welcome funding in Chicago and he ought to heed the warnings from the score businesses that his profligate spending spooks potential buyers.
“The downgrade displays our view that the 2025 price range leaves intact a large structural budgetary imbalance that we anticipate will make balancing the price range in 2026 and outyears tougher,” S&P mentioned in its report asserting the downgrade.
As a substitute of heeding the warnings of the rankings businesses to price range responsibly, the town doubled down, issuing a information launch wherein Chief Monetary Officer Jill Jaworski mentioned, “We don’t agree with this score adjustment.”
Whereas mistaken, the administration’s opinion of the downgrade is inconsequential, however the downgrade has actual penalties for Chicago taxpayers.
Mr. Mayor, the taxpayers and enterprise homeowners of Chicago are asking you to be fiscally accountable as a result of they need you to reach placing the town on a greater monetary observe the place individuals can afford to dwell right here, pay their taxes and run their companies right here.
Our collectors will not be our adversaries. And we lose once we view our stakeholders that manner. After I grew to become comptroller, I listened to the rankings businesses. I reached out to them. Listening to their recommendation prices you nothing and can provide you a clue on methods to restore investor confidence in Chicago with out short-changing taxpayers the best way your downgrades will.
Please hearken to the taxpayers, the champions of accountable budgeting, and the score businesses. Discover efficiencies in metropolis authorities. Not everybody who encourages you to price range responsibly is an enemy. We’re your constituents.
Meantime, I strongly urge the members of the Chicago Metropolis Council to vote “No” on the extra $830 million in borrowing. If Johnson insists on pursuing a path main Chicago over a fiscal cliff, you must select to keep away from that cliff dive. Chicagoans are relying on you to be the adults within the room and present fiscal self-discipline. You’ve the facility to cease this, so do it.
Susana A. Mendoza is the Illinois state comptroller, charged with paying the state’s payments. She served 10 years as a state legislator.
The views and opinions expressed by contributors are their very own and don’t essentially mirror these of the Chicago Solar-Occasions or any of its associates.
The Solar-Occasions welcomes letters to the editor and op-eds. See our guidelines.
Get Opinions content material delivered to your inbox.
